Grant/Mushin for Steve Smith (Car)? Yes or No

[dumbassmax2001 0]

My team is listed in my signature below. I was offered Ryan Grant & Mushin Muhammed for my Steve Smith (Car). Give me your thoughts if you don't mind.

 

Leave your link and I will gladly respond. Thanks.

[sick_n_tired 0]

that is a tough one. Ryan Grant has been an epic bust so far if he went in the mid-20's draft selection and a horrorshow if taken higher. But it has to end sometime soon & Brandon J. isnt going to take his job any time soon with what he has generated so far with his touches. I think the big Q is what is your RB situation, how badly do you need to get a RB. Obviously Smith is ready to break out and Muhammad seems to be playing like he is 30 again.

[grades 0]

I agree. If you need a RB, I would consider it. If not, I would stick with Steve Smith - starting to play better.

[We Tigers 71]

I'd stay put. Smith is really your only WR with elite potential, and since you have to start at least 3 receivers I think it'd be dangerous to trade him away. At this point, Grant is really no better than McGahee or Deuce, which means he doesn't add enough value to your backs to be worth the drop from Smith.

[Durtee 0]

I agree. If you need a RB, I would consider it. If not, I would stick with Steve Smith - starting to play better.

 

I agree with all of the responses... this pretty much sums it up

[Mr. Thanksgiving 0]

I don't think that helps your team enough. Smith is your only good receiver, and Grant would be like a RB#3. Mushin doesn't help much either, IMO. I don't think you have the WR depth to pull this one off.

 

Please see mine: http://www.fftodayforums.com/forum/index.p...howtopic=328991